Four Votes Between Two Records DINA Investigation By Professor Dr. Lent C. Carr, II, Ph.D. Chief Editor | Investigative Journalist | Political Analyst Democracy Independent News Association (DINA) Published: 2026-11-16 Original: https://www.dinanews247.press/articles/four-votes-between-two-records One North Carolina judicial recount request cites a 434-vote margin. The state’s precinct file adds up to 430. Five counties supply the audit trail. Andrew Brooks put a number in his November 13 letter asking North Carolina to recount a district judgeship. After the five county canvasses, he wrote, the margin was 434 votes. DINA added the returns for his seat in the state’s downloadable file. They give Republican Eric F. Eller 27,690 and Democrat Brooks 27,260, a difference of 430. Both records identify the same November 3 election for District Court Judge, District 35, Seat 1. Neither supplies the calculation behind the other figure. Brooks’s written request (https://s3.amazonaws.com/dl.ncsbe.gov/Legal/2026%20General%20Election/Recount%20Requests/District_Court_35_Seat%201_Brooks_Recount%20Request.pdf) · State precinct results (https://s3.amazonaws.com/dl.ncsbe.gov/ENRS/2026_11_03/results_pct_20261103.zip) There is now an answer to a separate question about the request. Watauga County says the State Board received it. The county set a recount meeting for Wednesday, November 18, at 10 a.m. at 814 W. King Street in Boone. Its public notice names Brooks and District 35. His signed letter supplies the seat number. The county gives no hour of receipt and the notice records a future meeting. County meeting notice and agenda (http://www.wataugacounty.gov/public-notices.aspx) How the counties add up Watauga supplied Brooks’s largest advantage. He received 14,630 votes there to Eller’s 9,000, a lead of 5,630. Eller led in the other four counties. In Avery he received 4,628 to Brooks’s 2,040, a margin of 2,588. Mitchell added 2,389 to Eller’s advantage, 4,259 to 1,870. Madison split 5,233 to 5,112, a difference of 121. Yancey split 4,570 to 3,608, a difference of 962. Those four margins add to 6,060. Subtract Watauga’s 5,630 and 430 remains. State precinct results (https://s3.amazonaws.com/dl.ncsbe.gov/ENRS/2026_11_03/results_pct_20261103.zip) DINA checked the arithmetic a second way. The export credits Eller with 11,995 Election Day votes, 15,112 early votes, 376 absentee-by-mail votes and 207 provisional votes. For Brooks the same columns give 6,260, 19,956, 815 and 229. Adding across the columns produces the same two district totals. Eller’s share of the 54,950 candidate votes is 50.3913 percent. Brooks’s is 49.6087 percent. The lead measures 0.7825 percentage points. The file supplies no verified district count of eligible ballots still outstanding or fraction of reporting units complete. What the public records can settle The state file carries a last-modified time of 7:05:43 p.m. Eastern on November 13. The letter bears that same calendar date and gives no hour. Its copy in the state repository carries a November 14 modification time. A server timestamp can date a particular copy. It cannot tell a reader which figures a candidate had in front of him when he signed. The difference between the two reported margins establishes neither four missing ballots nor a change in the lead. The state workbook lists November 18 starts for Avery, Madison, Mitchell and Yancey under District Court 35, without a seat number. Watauga’s own notice supplies the fifth county and identifies the candidate. A voter looking only at the state spreadsheet could miss the Boone meeting. A voter looking only at the Boone notice would miss four other counties’ figures. The two records serve different purposes and both belong in the public account. State recount schedule (https://s3.amazonaws.com/dl.ncsbe.gov/Legal/2026%20General%20Election/Recount%20Requests/Schedules_County_Board_Recounts_2026.xlsx) · Watauga public notice (http://www.wataugacounty.gov/public-notices.aspx) The records that could explain the four-vote difference are the five canvass abstracts used for Seat 1, any amended abstracts with timestamps, and the component totals behind the letter’s 434. A before-and-after return from each recount would answer a different question about whether the second tabulation changed anyone’s total. Until those records can be matched, 434 belongs to the candidate’s request, 430 to the state export, and the recount outcome and final certification remain open. REPUBLICATION NOTICE Original DINA-authored text may be republished without charge under the terms at https://www.dinanews247.press/syndication#terms. Third-party material and images require separate permission. SOCIAL POST Four Votes Between Two Records One North Carolina judicial recount request cites a 434-vote margin. The state’s precinct file adds up to 430. Five counties supply the audit trail. DINA Investigation By Professor Dr. Lent C. Carr, II, Ph.D. Chief Editor | Investigative Journalist | Political Analyst Democracy Independent News Association (DINA) Read the full report and sources: https://www.dinanews247.press/articles/four-votes-between-two-records #DINA #PublicAccountability